Headway, Alma, Grow: Do You Still Need Your Own EHR in 2026?

You've joined Headway, Alma, or Grow Therapy. They handle credentialing, billing, and provide a basic platform. So why are so many clinicians still paying for a separate EHR? The answer isn't straightforward, and it depends on your practice model, documentation needs, and long-term goals.

Quick Answer

Most clinicians using Headway, Alma, or Grow eventually need their own EHR for comprehensive documentation, data ownership, and business flexibility. Platform documentation meets minimum insurance requirements but lacks clinical depth, custom templates, assessment tools, and AI assistance. By year 2-3, 55% of platform users add a separate EHR. ClinikEHR complements these platforms perfectly: use the platform for insurance billing while maintaining professional-grade documentation in ClinikEHR. Start with the free plan ($0/month for 20 clients) for private pay clients, then upgrade to Professional ($79/month) for AI notes that save 15-20 minutes per session. You own all data, can leave platforms anytime, and build toward practice independence.

Why ClinikEHR Complements Insurance Platforms

Many clinicians use ClinikEHR alongside Headway, Alma, or Grow for features these platforms don't provide:

Pros of Adding ClinikEHR:

• Comprehensive clinical documentation beyond basic session notes
• AI-powered note generation that saves 15-20 minutes per session
• Treatment planning tools with measurable goals and progress tracking
• Assessment library with 20+ auto-scored mental health assessments
• Private pay client management separate from insurance clients
• Complete data ownership - export everything anytime
• Custom note templates tailored to your specialty and style
• Integrated telehealth for clients outside platform networks
• Long-term record keeping if you leave the platform
• Professional documentation for legal protection
• Free plan available ($0/month for up to 20 clients) - perfect for private pay clients

Let's explore what these platforms actually provide and where the gaps exist.

What Insurance Platforms Actually Provide

Headway: The Basics

What Headway Gives You:

• Credentialing with major insurance companies
• Claims submission and billing
• Basic scheduling calendar
• Simple session notes template
• Payment processing
• Client portal for booking

What Headway Doesn't Provide:

• Comprehensive treatment plans
• Assessment tools
• Custom note templates
• Detailed progress tracking
• Private pay client management
• Data export options
• Advanced clinical documentation
• Outcome measurement tools

Headway's Documentation:

• Basic SOAP note template
• Limited customization
• Minimal clinical detail
• Insurance-focused (not clinically comprehensive)
• No treatment plan builder

Alma: Middle Ground

What Alma Gives You:

• Insurance credentialing
• Billing and claims
• Scheduling system
• Session notes
• Client communication
• Payment processing
• Some practice management features

What Alma Doesn't Provide:

• Robust treatment planning
• Comprehensive assessments
• AI documentation assistance
• Advanced clinical tools
• Full data portability
• Specialty-specific templates
• Outcome tracking
• Research-grade documentation

Alma's Documentation:

• Better than Headway but still basic
• Some template options
• Insurance-compliant
• Limited clinical depth
• No AI assistance

Grow Therapy: Similar Limitations

What Grow Gives You:

• Insurance panel access
• Automated billing
• Basic scheduling
• Simple documentation
• Client matching
• Payment handling

What Grow Doesn't Provide:

• Advanced clinical documentation
• Treatment plan templates
• Assessment administration
• Custom workflows
• Private pay management
• Comprehensive data export
• AI note-taking
• Specialty tools

Grow's Documentation:

• Streamlined for efficiency
• Insurance-focused
• Limited customization
• Basic clinical content
• No advanced features

The Real Question: What Do You Actually Need?

Scenario 1: You're Starting Out

Your Situation:

• New to private practice
• 100% insurance-based
• Seeing 10-15 clients/week
• Simple practice model
• Limited budget

Platform Alone Might Work If:

• You're comfortable with basic notes
• You don't need detailed treatment plans
• Your specialty doesn't require extensive documentation
• You're not planning to add private pay clients
• You don't anticipate leaving the platform

Add Your Own EHR If:

• You want professional-grade documentation
• You're building toward private pay
• You need specialty-specific tools
• You want data ownership
• You value clinical depth

Recommendation: Start with platform alone, add ClinikEHR's free plan for private pay clients as they come.

Scenario 2: You're Growing

Your Situation:

• 1-2 years in practice
• 20-30 clients/week
• Mix of insurance and private pay
• Considering specialization
• Want better documentation

You Probably Need Your Own EHR Because:

• Platform documentation feels limiting
• You have private pay clients
• You want more clinical detail
• You need better organization
• You're thinking long-term

What to Look For:

• Affordable pricing (ClinikEHR: $29-79/month)
• Easy integration with current workflow
• Better documentation tools
• Private pay billing
• Data export options

Recommendation: Add ClinikEHR Professional Plan ($79/month) for comprehensive features.

Scenario 3: You're Established

Your Situation:

• 3+ years in practice
• 30+ clients/week
• Significant private pay percentage
• Specialized practice
• Professional reputation matters

You Definitely Need Your Own EHR Because:

• Documentation quality affects your reputation
• You need comprehensive clinical records
• Legal protection requires detailed notes
• You want to own your data
• You may leave platforms eventually
• You need advanced clinical tools

What You Need:

• Comprehensive EHR with all features
• AI documentation assistance
• Custom templates
• Assessment tools
• Treatment planning
• Outcome tracking

Recommendation: ClinikEHR Professional or Practice Plan for full capabilities.

The Hidden Costs of Platform-Only Practice

Documentation Quality

Platform Documentation:

• Meets minimum insurance requirements
• Lacks clinical depth
• Limited narrative space
• Template-driven (not customizable)
• Focused on billing, not care

Comprehensive EHR Documentation:

• Detailed clinical narratives
• Custom templates for your style
• Specialty-specific content
• Treatment plan integration
• Progress measurement

Why It Matters:

• Legal protection in disputes
• Professional credibility
• Better patient care
• Easier supervision
• Consultation clarity

Data Ownership

Platform Data:

• Stored on their servers
• Limited export options
• May lose access if you leave
• Restricted data portability
• Platform controls access

Your Own EHR Data:

• You own all records
• Export anytime
• Keep forever
• Full portability
• Complete control

Real-World Impact:

• What happens if platform shuts down?
• What if you're terminated?
• What if you want to leave?
• How do you transfer clients?
• Where are your records?

Clinical Limitations

What Platforms Can't Do:

• Comprehensive psychological testing
• Detailed treatment planning
• Outcome measurement
• Research-grade documentation
• Specialty-specific workflows
• Custom assessment batteries
• Progress visualization
• Collaborative care coordination

What This Means:

• Limited clinical sophistication
• Harder to demonstrate outcomes
• Difficult to track progress
• Less professional documentation
• Reduced clinical effectiveness

Business Flexibility

Platform Lock-In:

• Dependent on their policies
• Can't easily transition away
• Limited to their insurance panels
• Restricted to their fee structure
• No private pay infrastructure

Your Own EHR:

• Build independent practice
• Add private pay anytime
• Leave platforms when ready
• Control your business model
• Multiple revenue streams

Common Scenarios: When You Need Both

Scenario A: Insurance + Private Pay Mix

The Setup:

• Use Headway/Alma/Grow for insurance clients
• Use ClinikEHR for private pay clients
• Keep all clinical documentation in ClinikEHR
• Use platform only for billing

Why It Works:

• Best of both worlds
• Comprehensive documentation
• Flexible business model
• Data ownership
• Professional records

How to Implement:

1. Keep platform for insurance billing
2. Document all sessions in ClinikEHR
3. Copy insurance notes to platform (if required)
4. Manage private pay entirely in ClinikEHR
5. Build toward independence

Scenario B: Specialty Practice

The Setup:

• Platform for basic insurance billing
• ClinikEHR for specialty documentation
• Custom templates for your niche
• Assessment tools for your population
• Outcome tracking for effectiveness

Why It Works:

• Professional-grade documentation
• Specialty-specific tools
• Better patient outcomes
• Easier supervision
• Research capabilities

Examples:

• DBT practice needs diary cards and skills tracking
• EMDR needs phase-specific documentation
• Eating disorder treatment needs meal logs
• Trauma work needs detailed safety planning
• Couples therapy needs relationship assessments

Scenario C: Building Toward Private Pay

The Setup:

• Start with platform for steady income
• Use ClinikEHR from day one
• Document everything comprehensively
• Build private pay slowly
• Transition when ready

Why It Works:

• Financial stability during transition
• Professional documentation from start
• Easy to add private pay clients
• Smooth transition when ready
• No data migration needed

Timeline:

• Year 1: 90% insurance, 10% private pay
• Year 2: 70% insurance, 30% private pay
• Year 3: 50% insurance, 50% private pay
• Year 4: 30% insurance, 70% private pay
• Year 5: 100% private pay (or your ideal mix)

Scenario D: Group Practice

The Setup:

• Platform for insurance billing
• ClinikEHR for practice management
• Centralized documentation
• Provider collaboration
• Consistent standards

Why It Works:

• Better oversight
• Consistent documentation
• Easier supervision
• Professional standards
• Scalable systems

ClinikEHR Practice Plan Benefits:

• Multiple provider access
• Role-based permissions
• Centralized billing
• Consistent templates
• Practice-wide reporting

The Cost-Benefit Analysis

Platform-Only Costs

Direct Costs:

• Platform fees: 0-8% of revenue
• Limited features included
• No additional software costs

Hidden Costs:

• Time spent on inadequate documentation
• Risk of data loss
• Limited business flexibility
• Professional reputation impact
• Potential legal exposure

Total Annual Cost:

• $0-5,000 in platform fees
• Unknown opportunity costs
• Potential risk costs

Platform + EHR Costs

Direct Costs:

• Platform fees: 0-8% of revenue
• ClinikEHR: $0-948/year ($0-79/month)
• Total software: $0-6,000/year

Benefits:

• Comprehensive documentation
• Data ownership
• Business flexibility
• Professional credibility
• Legal protection
• Time savings (AI notes)
• Better patient care

ROI Calculation:

• AI notes save 15 min/session
• 20 sessions/week = 5 hours saved
• 5 hours × $100/hour = $500/week
• $500 × 48 weeks = $24,000/year
• Cost: $948/year
• Net benefit: $23,052/year

The Real Question

Is $79/month worth:

• Professional documentation?
• Data ownership?
• Business flexibility?
• Time savings?
• Legal protection?
• Better patient care?

For most established clinicians, the answer is yes.

What Clinicians Actually Do

Survey Results (2025 Data)

Clinicians Using Platforms:

• 45% use platform only
• 55% use platform + separate EHR

Why They Add an EHR:

• Better documentation (78%)
• Data ownership (65%)
• Private pay clients (62%)
• Specialty tools (54%)
• Long-term planning (48%)
• Legal protection (43%)

Why They Don't:

• Cost concerns (52%)
• "Good enough" documentation (38%)
• Don't know they need it (28%)
• Too busy to switch (22%)

Common Patterns

Year 1-2:

• Most use platform only
• Focus on building caseload
• Basic documentation sufficient
• Cost-conscious

Year 2-3:

• Many add separate EHR
• Documentation feels limiting
• Adding private pay clients
• Want more control

Year 3+:

• Most have separate EHR
• Professional documentation matters
• Business flexibility important
• Data ownership valued

Making the Decision

You Probably Don't Need Your Own EHR If:

• You're brand new to practice
• You're 100% insurance-based
• You're seeing fewer than 15 clients/week
• You're comfortable with basic notes
• You have no plans for private pay
• You're happy with platform documentation
• You're on a very tight budget

Recommendation: Start with platform alone, revisit in 6-12 months.

You Probably Need Your Own EHR If:

• You have any private pay clients
• You want comprehensive documentation
• You value data ownership
• You're building a specialty practice
• You plan to leave platforms eventually
• You want professional-grade records
• You need advanced clinical tools
• You're thinking long-term

Recommendation: Add ClinikEHR now, start with free or starter plan.

You Definitely Need Your Own EHR If:

• You have 30+ clients/week
• You have significant private pay percentage
• You're a specialist
• You supervise others
• You do forensic work
• You're building a group practice
• You want to own your business
• You value clinical excellence

Recommendation: ClinikEHR Professional or Practice Plan.

How to Integrate Both Systems

Workflow Option 1: Dual Documentation

Process:

1. See client on platform's telehealth
2. Write comprehensive note in ClinikEHR
3. Copy brief version to platform
4. Submit claim through platform
5. Keep detailed records in ClinikEHR

Pros:

• Best documentation
• Platform compliance
• Data ownership

Cons:

• Some duplication
• Extra 2-3 minutes per session

Workflow Option 2: ClinikEHR Primary

Process:

1. Use ClinikEHR for everything
2. Export insurance notes to platform
3. Submit claims through platform
4. Keep all records in ClinikEHR

Pros:

• Single source of truth
• Minimal duplication
• Comprehensive records

Cons:

• Requires export/import
• Slight learning curve

Workflow Option 3: Separate Streams

Process:

1. Insurance clients: Platform for everything
2. Private pay clients: ClinikEHR for everything
3. Keep streams separate
4. Consolidate for your records

Pros:

• Clear separation
• No duplication
• Simple to manage

Cons:

• Split documentation
• Two systems to check

Recommended Workflow

Best Practice:

1. Use ClinikEHR as your primary EHR
2. Document all sessions comprehensively
3. Use AI notes to save time
4. Export brief notes to platform (if required)
5. Submit claims through platform
6. Keep all detailed records in ClinikEHR
7. Build private pay in ClinikEHR

Time Investment:

• Initial setup: 2-3 hours
• Per session: 2-3 extra minutes
• Weekly: 30-60 minutes
• ROI: Significant

Why ClinikEHR is the Perfect Complement

Designed for This Use Case

Platform Integration:

• Easy to use alongside Headway/Alma/Grow
• Export notes in platform format
• Separate billing streams
• Flexible workflows

Comprehensive Features:

• Everything platforms lack
• Professional documentation
• AI assistance
• Custom templates
• Assessment tools
• Treatment planning

Pricing That Makes Sense

Flexible Plans:

• Free Plan: $0/month (20 clients) - perfect for private pay clients
• Starter Plan: $29/month (50 clients) - add comprehensive documentation
• Professional Plan: $79/month (unlimited, AI notes) - full features
• Practice Plan: $149/month (multiple providers) - group practices

No Hidden Fees:

• No per-claim charges (unlike platforms)
• No setup fees
• No long-term contracts
• Cancel anytime

Time-Saving AI Features

AI Documentation:

• Generate notes in 30 seconds
• Maintain your voice and style
• Insurance-compliant
• Clinically comprehensive
• Save 15-20 minutes per session

ROI Example:

• 20 sessions/week
• 15 minutes saved per session
• 5 hours saved weekly
• 240 hours saved annually
• Worth $24,000 at $100/hour
• Cost: $948/year
• Net benefit: $23,052/year

Data Ownership

Your Records, Your Control:

• Export everything anytime
• Keep records forever
• Full data portability
• No platform lock-in
• Complete ownership

Peace of Mind:

• What if platform shuts down?
• What if you're terminated?
• What if you want to leave?
• Your records are safe

Real Clinician Experiences

Case Study 1: Maria, LCSW

Background:

• 2 years on Headway
• 25 clients/week
• Started adding private pay

Problem:

• Headway notes felt inadequate
• Private pay clients needed separate system
• Wanted better documentation

Solution:

• Added ClinikEHR Professional Plan
• Documented all clients in ClinikEHR
• Copied brief notes to Headway
• Managed private pay in ClinikEHR

Results:

• Better documentation quality
• Easy private pay management
• Saved time with AI notes
• More professional records
• Peace of mind

Quote: "I wish I'd started with ClinikEHR from day one. The documentation quality alone is worth it, and the AI notes save me hours every week."

Case Study 2: Dr. James, Psychologist

Background:

• 3 years on Alma
• Specialty: trauma therapy
• Needed comprehensive documentation

Problem:

• Alma's notes too basic for trauma work
• Needed detailed treatment plans
• Required outcome measurement
• Wanted assessment tools

Solution:

• Added ClinikEHR Professional Plan
• Used specialty templates
• Administered assessments
• Tracked outcomes

Results:

• Professional-grade documentation
• Better patient outcomes
• Easier supervision
• Legal protection
• Research capabilities

Quote: "For specialty work, platform documentation just doesn't cut it. ClinikEHR gives me the clinical tools I need."

Case Study 3: Sarah, LMFT

Background:

• Started on Grow Therapy
• Building toward private pay
• Long-term vision

Problem:

• Didn't want to be platform-dependent
• Needed private pay infrastructure
• Wanted data ownership

Solution:

• Added ClinikEHR from month 1
• Documented everything comprehensively
• Built private pay gradually
• Transitioned over 2 years

Results:

• Now 70% private pay
• Smooth transition
• No data migration needed
• Professional documentation throughout
• Business independence

Quote: "Starting with ClinikEHR was the best decision. I built my practice on a solid foundation instead of having to migrate later."

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Do I really need my own EHR if I use Headway, Alma, or Grow? A: It depends on your practice model and goals. If you're brand new, 100% insurance-based, and comfortable with basic documentation, platform-only might work initially. However, if you have any private pay clients, want comprehensive documentation, value data ownership, or plan to build a specialty practice, you need your own EHR. Most established clinicians (55%) use both.

Q: What do insurance platforms not provide? A: Platforms lack comprehensive treatment planning, assessment tools, custom note templates, AI documentation assistance, detailed progress tracking, private pay client management, full data export options, specialty-specific tools, and outcome measurement capabilities. Their documentation meets minimum insurance requirements but lacks clinical depth.

Q: Can I use ClinikEHR alongside Headway or Alma? A: Yes, many clinicians use ClinikEHR as their primary EHR for comprehensive documentation while using platforms only for insurance billing. You document all sessions in ClinikEHR, then copy brief notes to the platform if required. This gives you professional-grade documentation, data ownership, and the billing convenience of platforms.

Q: What happens to my records if I leave Headway or Alma? A: Platform data export options are limited. You may lose access to detailed records if you leave or are terminated. This is why many clinicians keep comprehensive documentation in their own EHR like ClinikEHR - you own all records, can export anytime, and keep them forever regardless of platform status.

Q: How much does it cost to add an EHR to my platform practice? A: ClinikEHR offers flexible pricing: Free plan ($0/month for 20 clients), Starter ($29/month for 50 clients), Professional ($79/month for unlimited clients with AI notes), and Practice ($149/month for multiple providers). Most solo clinicians use the Professional plan at $79/month, which pays for itself through time savings from AI documentation.

Q: Will using two systems double my documentation time? A: No. With ClinikEHR's AI notes, you actually save time overall. Document comprehensively in ClinikEHR (faster with AI), then copy a brief version to the platform if required - adds only 2-3 minutes per session. The AI saves 15-20 minutes per session, so net time savings is 12-17 minutes per session.

Q: Can I manage private pay clients separately from insurance clients? A: Yes, this is a common setup. Use platforms for insurance clients and billing, while managing private pay clients entirely in ClinikEHR. This keeps streams separate, gives you flexibility, and allows you to build toward private pay without disrupting your insurance income. Many clinicians transition gradually using this approach.

Q: What if I'm just starting out - should I wait to add an EHR? A: Starting with ClinikEHR from day one is actually easier than migrating later. Use the free plan ($0/month) initially, document everything comprehensively from the start, and avoid data migration headaches later. Many clinicians regret not starting with proper documentation from the beginning. The free plan lets you test risk-free.

Conclusion

The question isn't really whether you need your own EHR alongside Headway, Alma, or Grow - it's when you need it and which one to choose.

For most clinicians, the answer is:

• Start with platform alone if you're brand new
• Add your own EHR within 6-12 months
• Use ClinikEHR's free plan to test
• Upgrade as your practice grows
• Build toward independence

The reality is:

• Platforms are great for insurance billing
• They're not comprehensive EHRs
• Most established clinicians use both
• The cost is minimal compared to benefits
• Data ownership matters
• Professional documentation protects you

With ClinikEHR, you get:

• Everything platforms lack
• Professional-grade documentation
• AI time savings
• Data ownership
• Business flexibility
• Affordable pricing

Ready to Upgrade Your Documentation?

Start with ClinikEHR's free plan and see the difference comprehensive documentation makes. No credit card required, no setup fees, and full access to core features.

Get started today:

1. Sign up free at clinikehr.com
2. Import your current clients
3. Try AI documentation
4. Keep using your platform for billing
5. Upgrade when ready

Questions about integrating ClinikEHR with your platform? Our support team has helped hundreds of clinicians make this transition smoothly. Contact us at [email protected] or visit our help center.

Join thousands of clinicians who've discovered the power of comprehensive documentation with ClinikEHR.

Related Reading on ClinikEHR

• Platform comparison: SimplePractice vs Alternatives | Private Pay vs Insurance Model
• Practice setup: How to Start a PMHNP Private Practice | Build Telehealth Private Practice from Scratch
• Documentation: Best AI Note-Taking for Psychiatry | Reduce Documentation Time
• Credentialing: Insurance Credentialing Made Simple | How to Start Billing Insurance on Your Own
• EHR guides: Best EHR for Solo Practice | Best EHR for Mental Health
• Marketing: How to Market Private Pay Therapy Practice | How to Get Therapy Clients Online